Frequently
Asked Questions about Wood Preservation
More Information |
Click for more information on the topics below:
|
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
|
|
 |
Links to other sources |
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
| |
|
 |
FPL Publications |
| |
Recent FPL Publications are generally availabe from our Web site at http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/
publications.html as PDF files. The most recent FPL publications are listed in "Dividends from Wood Research," FPL's semiannual listing of new publications. Sections of the listing relevant to wood preservation are "Durability" and "Decay Processes and Bioprocessing." |
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
|
Two chapters of the Wood Handbook are particularly relevant: |
| |
o |
|
| |
o |
|
Send comments to:
Carol Clausen, Project Leader
Wood Preservation
US Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory
One Gifford Pinchot Drive
Madison, WI 53726-2398
cclausen@fs.fed.us
|
|
| |
Q: What are the alternative types of treated
wood for residential use?
As health concerns about CCA increased, non-arsenic
copper-based treatments were developed and introduced in the marketplace.
Depending on your location and intended use of the wood, there may be
one or more alternative types of treated wood available for residential
use.
This listing describes only preservatives that have
been evaluated and standardized by the American Wood-Preservers' Association
(AWPA), which is the primary standard-setting body for pressure-treated
wood. To become standardized by the AWPA, preservative-treated wood must
undergo a series of rigorous tests to ensure its durability. Be wary of
purchasing wood that has been treated with a preservative that has not
been standardized for that application by the AWPA or some other major
standard-setting body, such as ASTM International.
Keep in mind that various suppliers may sell the same
type of treated wood by different trade names and that you may need to
ask the supplier for more information to determine the preservative used.
In many cases, the treated wood will have an end-tag that lists the active
ingredients. Also, some manufacturers incorporate colorants or water repellents
into some of their preservative treatments. Some treatments may not be
commercially available.
Information on what companies manufacture or distribute
preservatives listed in the AWPA standards can be found on the at www.awpa.com/suppliers/preservatives.asp.
The following preservatives are listed in alphabetical
order and are not ranked by any criteria. Statements on effectiveness
in this section are based on the literature and submittals to AWPA by
manufacturers. For information on testing that has been conducted by FPL,
see the next question, Has
FPL evaluated these treated wood products?
Acid Copper Chromate (ACC)
Acid copper chromate (ACC) has been used for decades
for treatment of wood used in cooling towers. It contains 31.8% copper
oxide and 68.2% chromium trioxide (AWPA P5). The solid, paste, liquid
concentrate, or treating solution can be made of copper sulfate, potassium
dichromate, or sodium dichromate. Tests on stakes and posts exposed to
decay and termite attack indicate that wood well impregnated with ACC
gives acceptable service, but it may be more prone to leaching than wood
treated with CCA. It is listed in AWPA standards for a wide range of softwood
and hardwood species, with a minimum retention of 4 kg/m3 (0.25
lb/ft3) or 8 kg/m3 (0.5 lb/ft3) for wood
used above ground or in ground contact, respectively. It may be difficult
to obtain adequate penetration of ACC in some of the more refractory wood
species such as white oak or Douglas-fir. This is partially because the
AWPA guideline for ACC require treating temperatures at or below 38/49ºC
(100/120ºF ) and because rapid reactions of chromium preservative
components in the wood can hinder further penetration during longer pressure
periods. Elevated temperatures can result in shallower penetration due
to faster fixation. ACC is used commercially, although in a limited number
of treating facilities.
Alkaline copper quat (ACQ) is one of several wood preservatives
that has been developed in recent years because of environmental or safety
concerns with CCA. The fungicides and insecticides in ACQ are expressed
as copper oxide (67%) and a quaternary ammonium compound (quat, 33%). Multiple
variations of ACQ have been standardized or are in the process of standardization.
ACQ type B (ACQ-B) is an ammoniacal copper quat formulation, ACQ type D
(ACQ-D) is an amine copper quat formulation, and ACQ type C (ACQ-C) is formulated
with either ammonia or amine and a slightly different quat compound. Wood
treated with ACQ-B wood has a dark greenish brown color that fades to a
lighter brown and may have an ammonia odor until the wood dries. Wood treated
with ACQ-D has a lighter greenish brown color and little noticeable odor.
Wood treated with ACQ-D weathers to a brown color. Wood treated with ACQ-C
varies in appearance between that of ACQ-B and ACQ-D, depending on the formulation.
Stakes treated with these three formulations have demonstrated efficacy
against decay fungi and insects when exposed in ground contact. The ACQ
formulations are listed in AWPA standards for a range of applications and
many softwood species, although the ACQ-C listings are limited because it
is the most recently standardized. Minimum retentions of 4 kg/m3 (0.25
lbs/ft3) or 6.4 kg/m3 (0.4 lbs/ft3) are
specified for wood used above ground or in ground contact, respectively.
The multiple formulations of ACQ allow some flexibility
in achieving compatibility with a specific wood species and application.
When ammonia is used as the carrier, ACQ has improved ability to penetrate
into difficult-to-treat wood species. However, if the wood species is
readily treated, such as southern pine, an amine carrier can be used to
provide a more uniform surface appearance. All the ACQ treatments do accelerate
corrosion of metal fasteners relative to untreated wood, and hot-dipped
galvanized or stainless steel fasteners are recommended. The number of
pressure treatment facilities using ACQ is increasing. In the western
United States, the ACQ-B formulation is primarily used because it allows
better penetration in difficult-to-treat western species, although ACQ-D
is being increasingly used. Treating plants in the remainder of the country
generally use the ACQ-D formulation. Use of the more recently standardized
ACQ-C formulation is expected to increase in both parts of the country.
Ammoniacal copper citrate (CC) is a recently developed wood preservative
that utilizes copper oxide (62%) as the fungicide and insecticide and
citric acid (38%) to aid in the distribution of copper within the wood
structure. The color of the treated wood varies from light green to dark
brown. The wood may have an ammonia odor until it is thoroughly dried
after treatment. Exposure tests with stakes and posts placed in ground
contact indicate that the treated wood resists attack by both fungi and
insects, although CC does not contain a co-biocide to prevent attack by
copper-tolerant fungi. CC is listed in AWPA standards for treatment of
a range of softwood species and wood products. The minimum CC retention
is 4 kg/m3 (0.25 lbs/ft3) or 6.4 kg/m3 (0.4
lb/ft3) for wood used above ground or in ground contact, respectively.
As with other preservatives containing ammonia, CC has an increased ability
to penetrate into difficult-to-treat wood species such as Douglas-fir.
CC treatments do accelerate corrosion of metal fasteners relative to untreated
wood, and stainless steel or hot-dipped galvanized fasteners are recommended.
Few treating plants currently use CC, and wood treated with this product
may not be readily available in most areas.
Copper azole is another recently developed preservative formulation that
relies primarily on amine copper, with co-biocides to protect wood from
decay and insect attack. The first copper azole formulation developed
was copper azole-Type A (CBA-A), which contains 49% copper, 49% boric
acid, and 2% tebuconazole. More recently, the copper azole-Type B (CA-B)
formulation was standardized. CA-B does not contain boric acid and contains
96% copper and 4% tebuconazole. Wood treated with either copper azole
formulation has a greenish-brown color and little or no odor. The copper
azole formulations have been evaluated with in-ground stake tests and
demonstrated efficacy against attack by decay fungi and insects. The formulations
are listed in AWPA standards for treatment of a range of softwood species.
Minimum retentions of CBA-A in the wood are 3.3 kg/m3 (0.20
lb/ft3 ) and 6.5 kg/m3 (0.41 lb/ft3)
for wood used above ground, or in ground contact, respectively. Minimum
retentions of CA-B in the wood are 1.6 kg/m3 (0.10 lb/ft3 or
3.4 kg/m3 (0.21 lb/ft3) for wood used above ground
or in ground contact, respectively. Although listed as an amine formulation,
copper azole may also be formulated with an amine-ammonia formulation.
The ammonia may be included when the copper azole formulations are used
to treat refractory species, and the ability of such a formulation to
adequately treat Douglas-fir has been demonstrated. The inclusion of the
ammonia, however, is likely to have slight affects on the surface appearance
and initial odor of the treated wood. The copper azole treatments do increase
the rate of corrosion of metal fasteners relative to untreated wood, and
hot-dipped galvanized or stainless steel fasteners are recommended. Because
copper azole has only been recently developed, relatively few treating
facilities are currently using this preservative.
Copper Dimethyldithiocarbamate (CDDC)
Copper dimethyldithiocarbamate (CDDC) is a reaction product
formed within the wood after treatment with two different treating solutions.
It contains copper and sulfur compounds. Exposure data indicates that
CDDC treatment is effective in protecting wood against attack by decay
fungi and insects, although a topical preservative finish may be needed
to prevent discoloration by mold and mildew. CDDC is standardized for
treatment of Southern Pine and some other pine species at copper retentions
of 1.6 kg/m3 (0.1 lbs/ft3) or 3.2 kg/m3 (0.2
lb/ft3) for wood used above ground or in ground contact, respectively.
CDDC-treated wood has a light brown color and has little or no odor. CDDC
has been developed very recently.
Borate Preservatives
Borate preservatives are sodium salts, such as sodium
octaborate, sodium tetraborate, and sodium pentaborate, that are dissolved
in water. Borate preservatives have received a lot of attention in recent
years because they are inexpensive and have low mammalian toxicity.
Borate-treated wood is also odorless and colorless and may be painted
or stained. Borates are effective preservatives against decay fungi
and insects. Borate preservatives are diffusible, and with appropriate
treating practices they can achieve excellent penetration in species
that are difficult to treat with other preservatives. Borate preservatives
are standardized by the AWPA but only for applications that are not
exposed to liquid water. The borate in the wood remains water soluble
and readily leaches out in soil or rainwater. Borate-treated wood should
be used only in applications where the wood is kept free from rainwater,
standing water, and ground contact. An example of such a use is in the
construction of wooden buildings in areas of high termite hazard. Borates
are also used in fire-retardant treatments.
Other Preservatives
Information on CCA and other preservative treatments can be found
in the following FPL publications:
|